
Perhaps you’d like to cut straight to the heart of the matter and listen to the podcast series. You can now find all five episodes wherever you get your podcasts. Here it is on Apple. Here is the series website, with transcripts, etc.
I.
In the 16th century, Tibetan Buddhist Dakpo Tashi Namgyal wrote Clarifying the Natural State, something of a practice manual for deep meditation. At the outset, he addressed the book to “those who…have had the occasion to believe.”
This is my preferred way of defining a “pivot point,” the subject of my new five-episode podcast series, out today. Someone’s first meditation experience that provokes belief, curiosity, or a general openness regarding just how strange, transformative, and meaningful meditation can get.
These experiences are gateways from a beginner’s practice, where meditation is popularly known as a stress-reliever, into the deep end, where, as neuroscientist Ruben Laukkonen puts it in the series: “meditation practice hits us somewhere deep enough that our understanding of reality has to change.”
Despite all of Buddhism’s lists and taxonomies and categorization schemes, I’ve found no equivalent to pivot points. The closest may be nyams in Tibetan Buddhism, often translated as “special” meditation experiences. Nyams are temporary altered states of consciousness, often full of bliss, clarity, or what’s sometimes called non-conceptual stillness. Basically, they’re interesting and exciting. But there is no distinction for the first nyam.
There’s something unique about someone’s first extremely strange and powerful meditation experience. These are first encounters with alien worlds of experience. “Your sense of self is a very stubborn illusion,” or “sometimes energy begins ramping up in your body until it pervades your entire field of awareness, your entire mind becomes a vibrating, pulsating field of ascending pleasure that shoots through the top of your head like a volcano until there is no body left, no you left, just the cooling field of awareness.” These are just words. And as people told me during interviews for this series, you cannot use words to imagine what these experiences are like before you’ve had them yourself.
Sean: I don’t think it is possible to correctly imagine it beforehand. Not because it’s anything particularly exotic, but just because you cannot actually imagine a new experience that you haven’t had before that is not decomposable into a composition of other elemental experiences you have had. When you hear people talk about it, you’re going to imagine something. That’s fine, we do that. But it won’t be correct because it cannot be.
A funny thing about meditation is that this whole process seems to simply repeat. The bottom of your understanding of the world drops out, again and again.
The first time it happens, we’re all starting on the same ground, more or less. We can all imagine what it means for a meditation experience to be relaxing. Or boring. Or a barrage of invasive thoughts. But what does it mean for a meditation experience to be transformative?
What experiences turn meditation from a wellness hobby into an existential inquiry? A spiritual practice? What experience could drive someone to spend their entire life meditating?
Pivot points introduce the experience of transformation into a practitioner’s understanding of meditation. They change the ballgame. In these shifts, things get both weird and fascinating. I have found very little media that examines them directly, or surveys the variety of first encounters with deep meditation experiences, or asks what insights these extremes of experience might hold for all of us creatures endowed, somewhat mysteriously, with consciousness.
Understandably, once a big meditation experience arrives, most people are generally interested in what’s next, and move on. Meditators want to go have the next experience. Teachers want to instruct students to continue moving along their path. But I think there’s value in sustaining our focus on these inaugural experiences. There is, at least, a mystery to sink into. And so, that is what this podcast series does.
II.
I worked with incredible partners on this project.
The Waking Up meditation app sponsored this whole ordeal. Though Pivot Points remains editorially independent, they provided helpful advice throughout. Special thanks to Nate Green, who wisely suggested I make the project a podcast rather than a Very Long Essay. He saved you all a lot of reading.
The theme music is an original composition by Marcus Bagala, an Emmy Award-winning composer. Valero Doval, who made the art for Serial and This American Life’s excellent podcast series, S-Town, created the cover art. Lucas Del Calvo mixed the rough audio files I sent him, which I recorded inside of my closet while surrounded by blankets, into a condition that pleases the ear. And Amy Standen, senior editor of the Pulitzer-finalist Ear Hustle podcast, took on the gargantuan task of helping to edit the script into narrative audio format. Wherever the script errs, it is likely because I ignored her advice.
The series exists thanks to all of those who agreed to appear on the other side of the microphone. I interviewed some of the best meditation teachers around: Michael Taft, Tina Rasmussen, Henry Shukman, Richard Shankman, and Charlie Awbery. Similarly, I convinced some of the best scientists working on advanced meditation to give me an hour, or in some cases three, of their time: Ruben Laukkonen, Mark Miller, Kathryn Devaney, Lars Sandved-Smith, Georg Northoff, Aviva Berkovich-Ohana, Idil Sezer, and Nicholas Bowles.
Some 40 meditators shared their experiences with me. That was a courageous thing to do. Some openly worried to me that if their employers heard their experiences, they could lose their jobs. Or at least be looked upon as an extremely strange colleague. While I made sure not to publish anything that could actually jeopardize anyone’s employment, I’m grateful to everyone who trusted me with their experiences.
III.
The main five episodes are free. Paid subscribers to this newsletter will also receive access to a list of bonus episodes. There is, at present, one bonus episode already published. It tells the story of the strangest, most advanced experience I heard in all my interviews. More will be published on a rolling & completely mysterious basis.
I would love to continue making projects like this. If you would like to support me in that endeavor, there are a few things you can do, aside from becoming a paid subscriber.
Text the series to a friend who you think would get a kick out of it. Drop it in your group chat, your organization’s newsletter, or just go shout its name from a nearby street corner. Or I suppose you could just post it on social media. It’s shocking how much more effective word of mouth is than every other podcast marketing strategy combined.
Press the ‘follow’ button on the show’s Apple Podcasts page. The more traction it gets over there in the first week, the higher the odds that it gets featured on their trending charts, which would spread tales of strange meditation experiences across the land.
Perhaps you have ideas for how to support, spread, or sustain this project that I haven’t even considered. Surely, the collective ‘you’ reading this can conceive of more possibilities than the singular ‘I’ writing it. If so, perhaps you should email me your thoughts.
IV.
I might as well give you a sense of what I discovered, some 40 hours of interviews later. Of course, I can’t. It isn’t possible. Nevertheless.
I heard plenty of tales. I heard of meditators accidentally stumbling upon the bliss of the first jhana while driving, which was extremely surprising and forced them to pull over and yell out loud: “What the hell was that?”
I heard scientists explain what the new research focusing on advanced meditation can tell us about why these experiences arise, and what they do to the mind. One scientist spoke of research on advanced meditation as a new source of faith in the practice.
Lars: What we have faith in in the West is science. And so in order to have the kind of faith to embark on this journey before you’ve even collected your own data, there needs to be a kind of source or reason for that. And the religious or spiritual context doesn’t do that for most people. And I’m hoping that the science can get to a place where they kind of gets people over the hump.
I heard similar explanations from teachers, albeit from the perspective of tradition and experience rather than mathematical models of the mind. I also heard those teachers lament the general taboo around discussing these experiences, and invite more engagement with them.
Initially, I set out to try and help dispel a little of the foggy mystery surrounding deep meditation. Instead, I was consumed by it. The mystery’s fumes made their way inside my mind. But what I found was that mystery is not an obstacle to deeper inquiry. Making progress on deepening meditation, or understanding consciousness in general, does not necessarily mean replacing mystery with understanding.
What pivot points appear to do is bust a hole in your understanding of, and relationship with, the world, so that the mystery gets inside. And the more you can experience it directly, the more it unfolds. The more of you it fills. And it turns out that this is, in fact, only the beginning.
I’ve been working through meditation teacher Ken McLeod’s book, A Trackless Path. Therein, he writes: “…to know directly the mystery of awareness, the mystery of this experience we call life, we have to let the conceptual mind go.”
At the same time, the conceptual mind can be used to bring us right up to the brink of letting go. It can orient us, point us in helpful directions. I hope this series aids in that regard. At the very least, you will hear some tales.
You can find the series wherever you get your podcasts. Apple, Spotify, Youtube, even inside the Waking Up app. The website has transcripts and all the rest.
it's great! congrats. cool website too
Thanks for sharing 😄 Opening with a 16th century manual addressed to "those who have had the occasion to believe" is a great way into pivot points.